The State of the Scientific Problem Concerning
the Study of the Main Characteristics of the Molten
Corium-Concrete Interaction Products

K. O. Sushchenko, A. V. Nosovskyi

Institute for Safety Problems of Nuclear Power Plants, NAS of Ukraine, 36a, Kirova st., Chornobyl, 07270, Ukraine

DOI: doi.org/10.31717/2311-8253.23.2.4

Abstract

In severe beyond-design basis accidents with loss of coolant and destruction of the core, the fuel melt (corium) can escape from the vessel and move to the concrete base of the reactor shaft. An analysis of the calculations results and modeling experiments shows possible options for the formation of unorganized compositions with a critical mass of fuel in the molten corium-concrete interaction products (MCCI). In the presence of water as a mobile and uncontrolled component in such compositions, there is a possibility of a self-sustaining chain reaction (SCR). To ensure the subcriticality control of such compositions, computational and experimental studies of the SCR occurrence in the volume of MCCI cluster are carried out. The problem of eliminating the probability of SCR occurrence in the volume of MCCI cluster was solved by choosing sacrificial materials (SM) used in melt localization devices (MLD). Effective neutron multiplication factors (Kef) were obtained for the MCCI, depending on the mass of the SM and its type. On the basis of computational and experimental studies, it was shown that when corium interacts with concrete, an interlayer of destroyed concrete is formed at the boundary of which there is a ceramic crust, which allows water to be retained in the breeding system. Also, MCCI is a twolayer structure containing immiscible metal and oxide components. After the accident at the Chornobyl nuclear power plant, as information about fuel-containing materials (FCM) was accumulated, work was carried out on the nuclear safety (NS) estimation of the Shelter object. Calculations of neutron-physical parameters of homogenous FCM mixtures during water intake made it possible to estimate the range of fuel parameters at which the existence of a critical composition and the occurrence of SCR in the process of water intake are possible. With mixed fuel burnup 11,5÷12,5 MW · day/kgU the critical mass of the FCM breeding medium should be 15÷30 t with a mass fraction of uranium (U) 45÷60% and the moisture capacity is no less than 40% by volume. It is known that Kef for FCM clusters depends on the mass and mass content of uranium, elemental composition of the mixture, geometric dimensions, reflectors, temperature, concentration of water as a mobile component. All the above calculations were carried out only for FCM with a fuel mass content of 5÷15%. It is shown that all FCM clusters localized inside the Shelter object are nuclear safe, except for the cluster in the south-eastern part of the subreactor room 305/2. A nuclear dangerous cluster (NDC) was formed in the two-meter monolith of a reinforced concrete base plate (BP) penetration zone. NDC is a water-uranium system with low-enriched fuel. The estimation of the fuel mass in the NDC by thermometric measurements, as well as the determination (by the downholes of research boreholes) of its geometry allow us to state that there is the critical mass of fuel (18–20 t of U) located in a limited volume. The specificity of water-uranium breeding systems with low-enriched fuel is the existence of two criticality values. In June 1990, re-criticality (cold critical incident) occurred when water entered the cooling NDC. SCR self-extinguishing occurred due to overmoistening of the breeding medium. Before the installation of NSC “Arch” (November 2016), the NDC was in a waterlogged state (according to the second criticality value) due to the rainwater inflow in the NDC localization zone. Water was a stabilizing factor. After the NSC installation and the termination of water access to the NDC localization zone, a constant increase in neutron activity is observed, which can only be related to the processes of water loss through the porous breeding medium of the NDC. A decrease in the concentration of water in the breeding medium can lead to “recurrent” criticality with consequences that are difficult to predict. According to the results of the calculations, a range of the main parameters of the NDC model was obtained, which ensure the presence of two criticality values in the process of water inflow to the breeding medium and do not contradict the available experimental data. All calculations of the neutron-physical characteristics of the NDC were carried out on the basis of modeling of the version of critical assemblies for the uranium silicate version of the physical model. Its chemical composition was determined on the basis of mixing fuel tablets into the silicate matrix of the FCM cluster. Taking into account the impossibility of the NDC formation in this way, since the concentration of uranium reaches no more than 15% during admixture, an uranium-zirconium model of the NDC was proposed as a MCCI product. Taking into account the growth of neutron activity in the south-eastern part of room 305/2, and assuming the possibility of “recurrent criticality” in the NDC breeding medium, it is necessary to revise the calculations of the NDC neutron-physical characteristics, to form and investigate a new uranium-zirconium NDC physical model as a MCCI product.

Keywords:

References

1. Akers D. W., Jensen S. M., Schuetz B. K. (1994). Examination of relocated fuel debris adjacent to the lower head of the TMI‑2 reactor vessel. Washington, DC: Nuclear Regulatory Commission. doi.org/10.2172/10140801.

2. Artamonov N. V., Sidorov A. S. (2012). [Changes in the breeding properties of a VVER-1000 reactor during a beyond design basis accident with a core meltdown]. Problems of Atomic Science and Technology. Series “NPP Safety Ensuring”, vol. 31, pp. 102–111. (in Rus.)

3. Bilodid I., Duspiva J. (2015). [Analysis of fuel criticality during severe accidents]. Nuclear and Radiation Safety, vol. 4 (68), pp. 3–8.

4. Sehgal, B. R. (2001). Accomplishments and challenges of the severe accident research. Nuclear Engineering and Design, vol. 210, no. 1–3, pp. 79–94. doi.org/10.1016/s0029–5493 (01) 00433–2

5. Kazachkov I. V. (2003). [Current state and some problems of severe accident simulation at foreign NPPs]. Nuclear and Radiation Safety, vol. 1, pp. 25–34. (in Rus.)

6. Kazachkov I. V. (2009). [The problem of corium melt cooling in containment in passive systems for protection against severe accidents. Part 1]. Nuclear and Radiation Safety, vol. 1, pp. 34–41. (in Rus.)

7. Beshta S. V. (2004). Vysokotemperaturnye processy s rasplavami koriuma v probleme bezopasnosti AES s VVER. [High-temperature processes with corium melts in the problem of safety of nuclear power plants with VVER]. (Doctoral dissertation). Saint Petersburg, [s. n.], 462 p. (in Rus.)

8. Bezlepkin V. V. (2003). Razrabotka problemnoorientirovannyh podhodov k obespecheniiu bezopasnosti novyh proektov AES s VVER [Development of problemoriented approaches to ensuring the safety of new NPP projects with VVER]. (Doctoral dissertation). Saint Petersburg, [s. n.], 381 p. (in Rus.)

9. Sidorov A. S. (2004). Lokalizaciia i ohlazhdenie koriuma v zaproektnoi avarii vodo-vodianogo energeticheskogo reaktora pri razrushenii aktivnoi zony [Localization and cooling of the corium in a beyond design basis accident of a pressurized water power reactor during the destruction of the core]. (PhD thesis). Moscow, [s. n.], 160 p. (in Rus.)

10. Chin Kyong. (2001). Razrabotka metodiki rascheta teploobmena v zadache lokalizacii rasplava aktivnoi zony VVER v podreaktornoi lovushke pri tjazheloi avarii na AES. [Development of a method for heat transfer calculation in the problem of localizing the melt of the VVER core in a sub-reactor trap during a severe accident at a nuclear power plant]. (PhD thesis). Moscow, [s. n.], 148 p. (in Rus.)

11. Artamonov N. V., Sidorov A. S. (2012). Obosnovanie jadernoi bezopasnosti ustroistva lokalizatsii rasplava dlia AES s reaktorami tipa VVER. [Justification of nuclear safety of the melt localization device for nuclear power plants with VVER-type reactors]. Yadernaia energetika [Nuclear
energy], vol. 3, pp. 23–31. (in Rus.)

12. Zhdanov V. S. (2008). Vzaimodeistvie rasplava aktivnoi zony s materialami reaktornoi ustanovki v probleme tiazheloi avarii VVER. [Interaction of the core melt with reactor plant materials in the problem of a VVER severe accident]. (PhD thesis). Saint Petersburg, [s. n.], 162 p. (in Rus.)

13. Spengler C., Allelein H., Cranga M., Duval F., Dorsselaere J. V. (2005) Assessment and development of molten corium concrete interaction models for the integral code ASTEC. Proceedings of Forum Eurosafe Bruxelles (BELGIQUE) (November 7–8), pp. 169–189. (in Rus.)

14. Miassoedov A., Alsmeyer H., Cron T., Foit, J. (2010). The comet-L3 experiment on long-term melt–concrete interaction and cooling by surface flooding. Nuclear Engineering and Design, vol. 240 (2), pp. 258–265. doi.org/10.1016/j. nucengdes.2008.12.005.

15. OECD, Nuclear Energy Agency (2017). State-of-the-art report on molten corium concrete interaction and ex-vessel molten core coolability. doi.org/10.1787/c44872b1-en.

16. Vysotskyi Ye. D., Godun R. L., Sushchenko K. O. (2020). [Expert assessment of the current criticality level of clusters of fuel-containing materials after the New Safe Confinement installation]. Nuclear Power and the Environment, vol. 16, no. 1, pp. 49–56.

17. I. V. Kurchatov Institute of Atomic Energy (1990). [Nuclear Safety analysis for the Shelter object (TOYaB)]. Moscow, [s. n.], 130 p. (in Rus.)

18. Physical and Energy Institute named after A. I. Leipunsky (1996). [Development of a scenario and methodology for assessing the consequences of SSCR during FCM handling and water ingress. Technical reference]. Obninsk: [s. n.], 22 p. (in Rus.)

19. Institute of Nuclear Energy of the Academy of Sciences of the BSSR (1990). [Nuclear safety analysis of the Shelter object. Report]. Minsk, [s. n.], 80 p. (in Rus.)

20. ISTC (1996). [Analysis of the current safety of the Shelter object and predictive assessments of the situation development. Report]. Chornobyl, [s. n.], 272 p. (in Rus.)

21. ChNPP (2002). [Report on the safety status of the Shelter object]. Chornobyl: Chornobyl NPP, 194 p. (in Rus.)

22. Pavlovych V. M. (2002). Nuclear fuel in the destroyed 4th unit of Chernobyl NPP. Recent Research Activities about
the Chernobyl NPP Accident in Belarus, Ukraine and Russia. Osaka: Research Reactor Institute, Kyoto University, pp. 45–58.

23. Borovoi A. A., et al. (2002). [Development of techniques and methods for monitoring the subcriticality state of fuel-containing materials, experimental study of the effectiveness of early detection criteria and technologies for local suppression of subcritical anomalies (Research Report)]. Chornobyl: ISP NPP NAS of Ukraine. (in Rus.)

24. Gmal B., Moser E. F., Pretsch G., Quade W. (1997). [Analysis and evaluation of the “Technical Substantiation of the Nuclear Safety of the Shelter object”. FCM criticality behavior at the Shelter object. GRS report by project SR-2075/8–1, work item 1, GRS-A-2414.], 44 p. (in Rus.)

25. Vertsimakha O. Ya., Pavlovich V. N., Babenko V. A., et. al. (1998). [Some issues of nuclear safety of the Shelter object]. Nuclear and Radiation Safety, vol. 1 (2), pp. 52–67. (in Rus.)

26. Pavlovich V. N., Babenko V. A., Vysotskyi Ye. D., Klyuchnikov A. A., Shevchenko V. G. (2005). [Model of neutron flux density distribution in the volume of fuel-containing materials in room 305/2 of the Shelter object]. Problems of Nuclear Power Plants Safety and of Chornobyl, vol. 2,
pp. 55–60. (in Rus.)

27. Babenko V. A., Vysotskyi Ye. D., Klyuchnikov A. A., Lagunenko A. S., Pavlovich V. N., Pazukhin E. M. (2008). [Modeling of the mass and geometric parameters of the accumulation of fuel-containing materials in the southeastern part of room 305/2 of the destroyed 4th unit of the ChNPP]. Problems of Nuclear Power Plants Safety and of Chornobyl, vol. 9, pp. 36–43. (in Rus.)

28. ISP NPP NAS of Ukraine (2010). [Research of nuclearphysical parameters and development of methods and ways of control and management of subcriticality in criticality risk zones. Research Report]. Chornobyl: ISP NPP NAS of Ukraine, 127 p. (in Rus.)

29. ISP NPP NAS of Ukraine (2015). [Development of measures to improve the nuclear, radiation and environmental safety of the Shelter object and the New Safe Confinement. Volume 1. Investigation of the neutron-physical and physicochemical characteristics of nuclear-hazardous clusters
and the development of methods for suppressing their criticality parameters. Research Report]. Chornobyl: ISP NPP NAS of Ukraine, 127 p. (in Rus.)

30. IBRAE RAN (1992). [The conclusion of the expert commission on the causes of the anomalous event in room 304/3 of the Shelter object in July 1990]. Institute for Problems of Safe Development of Nuclear Energy of the Russian Academy of Sciences, 67 p. (in Rus.)

31. Frolov V. V. (1996). [Anomalous incident on June 27–30, 1990 in the Shelter object of the Chornobyl nuclear power plant]. Atomic energy, vol. 3 (80), pp. 216–219. (in Rus.)

32. Vysotskyi Ye. D., Klyuchnikov A. A., Shcherbin V. N., Shostak V. B. (2009). [Neutron-Pphysical characteristics of nuclear-hazardous accumulations of fuel-containing materials]. Problems of Nuclear Power Plants Safety and of Chornobyl, vol. 12, pp. 93–102. (in Rus.)

33. Vysotskyi Ye. D., Klyuchnikov A. A., Lagunenko A. S., et al. (2011). [Nuclear-dangerous clusters of fuel-containing materials in the destroyed fourth unit of the Chornobyl nuclear power plant]. Radiochemistry, vol. 2 (53), pp. 178–183.

Full Text (PDF)

---